NeurIPS 2020

Dynamic Regret of Convex and Smooth Functions

Meta Review

Four knowledgeable referees evaluated the paper. Three recommend acceptance with good arguments. A fourth recommends rejection, but with a very short review claiming in particular that the result can be assembled from existing ingredients. The referee did not respond to either the author rebuttal or my request in the subsequent discussion asking for details. It is my opinion that such a review should at least be substantiated with references, so I am choosing to discount this review.