NeurIPS 2020

General Transportability of Soft Interventions: Completeness Results

Meta Review

The paper describes a sound and complete algorithm for identifying responses to soft interventions for transportability problems. The reviewers found the paper interesting and novel, although they found the presentation difficult to follow for an interested member of the NeurIPS community not intimately familiar with details of identification theory. I must second the disappointment expressed in one of the comments of reviewer 2, regarding the somewhat selective "citation discipline" in this paper.