Sun Dec 8th through Sat the 14th, 2019 at Vancouver Convention Center
I think the paper addresses an interesting problem, albeit limited in scope to computer vision. I am sure practitioners in that field will appreciate the paper's findings. Two of the reviewers were positive, and reaffirmed their position during the post-rebuttal discussion, while R1 remained concerned, in particular regarding lack of rigorous statistical analysis of the results. The other reviewers did not consider that issue a deal-breaker, and I agree and recommend to accept.